Newest Casey Key Properties for Sale

Nestled on the serene expanse of North Casey Key, this sprawling 1.5-acre Gulf-to-Bay estate presents an extraordinary opportunity to possess a slice of paradise. From it...

4 Beds
4 Baths
Casey Key SubDv.
34229 Zip Code

1544 N Casey Key Road, Osprey $10,500,000

Along the beaches of Casey Key, a private gated road leads to the exclusive northern end of this coveted barrier island. Sited on nearly 2.5 acres and 150 feet of privat...

6 Beds
7.5 Baths
Casey Key SubDv.
34229 Zip Code

4020 Casey Key Road, Nokomis $2,000,000

One of the few remaining vacant bayfront parcels on Casey Key. Nearly one acre of land and 130 +/- feet of bay frontage to build the home of your dreams. Near the north B...

Casey Key SubDv.
34275 Zip Code

5652 Semolino St, Nokomis $650,000

Have you ever dreamed of living in paradise? Well then, STOP THE CAR! This home is offered turnkey furnished and you can literally bring your toothbrush and your clothes ...

2 Beds
2 Baths
Bellacina By Casey Key SubDv.
34275 Zip Code

2821 Casey Key Road, Nokomis $12,500,000

When you come up the steps and enter the Courtyard Gates the Black Lagoon Pool & Spa are to your left and on your right is a Rock Wall Waterfall both created by Lucas Lag...

5 Beds
6 Baths
Casey Key SubDv.
34275 Zip Code

5764 Semolino Street, Nokomis $699,900 ▼

This exquisite single-family residence, boasting 2 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, and a dedicated office space, is a masterpiece of modern architecture. Constructed in 2020, this...

2 Beds
2 Baths
Bellacina By Casey Key SubDv.
34275 Zip Code

5733 Semolino Street, Nokomis $749,900

The ULTIMATE Florida lifestyle is at your fingertips!! Check out this popular 2 Bed/2 Bath PLUS DEN Roma model in the sought after community of BELLACINA BY CASEY KEY! Im...

2 Beds
2 Baths
Bellacina By Casey Key SubDv.
34275 Zip Code

2812 Casey Key Road, Nokomis $3,250,000

Discover the epitome of waterfront living at this stunning Casey Key bayfront estate! Boasting 121 feet of prime intercoastal waterway frontage, this property is a paradi...

3 Beds
3 Baths
Casey Key SubDv.
34275 Zip Code

5741 Puccini Street, Nokomis $699,000

DON'T MISS OUT!! This gorgeous home is now available. Sitting on a corner lot surrounded by tropical landscaping with extra yard space this home is a tropical paradise....

3 Beds
2 Baths
Bellacina By Casey Key SubDv.
34275 Zip Code

2410 Casey Key Road, Nokomis $3,995,000

If you are looking for a slice of island paradise for your winter escape, or seeking incredible quality of life to enjoy year-round, this gem on the barrier island of Cas...

2 Beds
2 Baths
Casey Key SubDv.
34275 Zip Code

5824 Semolino Street, Nokomis $655,000

COME AND SEE THIS BEAUTIFUL HOME TODAY!! JUST LIKE NEW is this Popular Roma floor plan offering 2BD/2BA/Den. Meander up the pavered sidewalk through a tropical landscape...

2 Beds
2 Baths
Bellacina By Casey Key SubDv.
34275 Zip Code

426 N Casey Key Road, Osprey $4,900,000

Gulf to Bay on North Casey Key – the perfect location! Panoramic views of Little Sarasota Bay to the east and a beachfront lot on the west. Original cypress tongue and gr...

3 Beds
2 Baths
Casey Key SubDv.
34229 Zip Code

922 Casey Cove Drive, Nokomis $1,975,000 ▼

Casey Key is an amazing place to live. This home is sitting on the Intracoastal waterway, aka Blackburn Bay with stunning views of the wide water way to your east & south...

2 Beds
2 Baths
Casey Key SubDv.
34275 Zip Code

616 S Casey Key Road, Nokomis $1,500,000

This true beach retreat on Casey Key provides you with a private deeded access wide pathway to the sandy beach on the Gulf of Mexico and a dock easement across the street...

2 Beds
1.5 Baths
Casey Key SubDv.
34275 Zip Code

624 S Casey Key Road, Nokomis $1,950,000 ▼

Experience your own private paradise! Discover unspoiled beaches and secluded coastlines in the peaceful community of Casey Key. Nestled on a prime lot, this remarkable ...

3 Beds
2.5 Baths
Casey Key SubDv.
34275 Zip Code

1704 Casey Key Road, Nokomis $5,995,000 ▼

Remarkable Gulf to Bay waterfront estate on the highly exclusive Island enclave of Casey Key, where opulence and serenity unite in perfect harmony. The highly sought-afte...

3 Beds
4.5 Baths
Casey Key Estates SubDv.
34275 Zip Code

3201 Casey Key Road, Nokomis $5,200,000

Welcome to Osmyrrah, a blending of the senses. With a focus on the white sand beach and tranquil seascape, this quintessential beach home was designed for organic, relaxe...

4 Beds
4 Baths
Casey Key SubDv.
34275 Zip Code

3909 Casey Key Road, Nokomis $7,950,000 ▼

Refined elegance in a near-perfect location just steps from the white sandy beach, this 2018-built Casey Key gulf front estate has it all. Upon entering through the custo...

4 Beds
4.5 Baths
Casey Key SubDv.
34275 Zip Code

3761 Casey Key Road, Nokomis $4,250,000 ▼

If you’ve ever dreamed of living on the beach, collecting shells on the shore and watching the sunset and stars come out every night, this may be your dream come true. Ne...

1 Beds
1 Baths
Casey Key SubDv.
34275 Zip Code

4019 Casey Key Road, Nokomis $10,000,000 ▼

The last residential build of Carl Abbott’s illustrious career is realized in the aptly named Gulf of Mexico estate. Though built on land, the architecture is suspended b...

4 Beds
4.5 Baths
Casey Key SubDv.
34275 Zip Code

Casey Key Rd, Nokomis $12,000,000

Pre-Construction. To be built. Stunning modern bayfront estate is situated on 1.4 acres with 250FT of bay frontage and a dock on boatable water. The residence will featur...

5 Beds
5.5 Baths
Casey Key SubDv.
34275 Zip Code

476 N Casey Key Road, Osprey $6,872,900 ▼

Looking for a barrier island with no high rises, no traffic jams, exclusivity, resident owned beaches, privacy, great medical, dining, and shopping all extremely convenie...

3 Beds
3.5 Baths
Casey Key SubDv.
34229 Zip Code

3999 Casey Key Road, Nokomis $3,997,000 ▲

Gulf Front "Vintage Florida Cottage" perched on a half an acre, and freshly updated from top to bottom, plus turn-key furnished with everything new! New luxury vinyl wate...

2 Beds
2 Baths
Casey Key SubDv.
34275 Zip Code

Casey Key Properties for Sale

Some of Florida's most upscale West Coast addresses are found on Casey Key. Casey Key is a dream destination for any homebuyer seeking to spend their days in the sun and the sand and their evening watching the sunset on the water during a Gulf-front dinner. While the community isn’t exciting by tourists’ standards, it is paradise for homebuyers seeking a laid-back lifestyle seemingly far removed from all the hustle and bustle, yet close enough to enjoy incredible services, amenities, and attractions. In fact, some might say Casey Key is one of the best-kept secrets among all of Florida’s gems.

This remarkable barrier island has a touch of Old Florida charm and an abundance of natural beauty. Throughout the community you’ll find subtropical foliage, including Pine trees and Palm trees. Casey Key Road is the only passageway in the area and Casey Key homes sit on both sides of it. Additionally, there are only two bridges connecting the island to the mainland. The northern bridge, Blackburn Point Bridge, is at Blackburn Point Road, and is one of the country’s two remaining 1920s swing bridges; while the southern bridge is at the other end of the island at Albee Road West. Though there is limited access to public services on the island, residents can easily enjoy the innumerable options in Sarasota and Venice.

Real estate in Casey Key is as varied as the area’s spectacular amenities. There are family vacation homes, estates, villas, and even million-dollar luxury homes in Casey Key. Casey Key real estate also includes a handful of low-rise condos, a few hotels, and some older Casey Key beach properties. Speaking of beach properties in Casey Key, the community has the largest concentration of them in the Sarasota area. Additionally, many of the Casey Key properties stretch from the Gulf side to the Bay side, because the island is so narrow. It is also more remote and secluded than Siesta Key, Longboat Key, Lido Key, and Bird Key. We would love to provide you with details about available Casey Key waterfront homes, so please contact us today so we can assist you with your Casey Key home search.

Our website features the best Casey Key real estate search for homes, condos, land and foreclosure properties available. It is the only site you will ever need! It is easy-to-use and updated by the official REALTOR®’s database every 15 minutes.

You can save searches, and get daily email alerts of new listings, price changes, sold data, and market reports. Our Interactive Map Search allows you to view properties on a map or refine your search by drawing the boundaries around the area you desire.

Casey Key Popular Searches

Casey Key Properties by Price

Casey Key Properties by # of Bedroom(s)

Casey Key Properties by # of Bathroom(s)

Curious about what’s happening in the Casey Key real estate market? Sign up for a Casey Key Real Estate Market Report to see what’s active, under contract, and sold!